Showing posts with label Henry Benning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Henry Benning. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 2, 2023

PhD sketchbooks: IBJ (30/10/20 - 3/5/21)

Mostly planning a presentation for that paper, a load of stuff for Disorder, drawings I did as a result of one of the funniest things that's ever happened to me, and distractions with Charley and Ann (which I'll use for some postdoctoral thing focussing on them, currently it's looking like it'll be a graphic novel about memory and time or something like that)

(Timelapse video of this one here!)

First page sideways because it wasn't entirely relevant to the main part of my work - I found out about a terrible fire in Barnard Castle when Charley and Ann were living there, and got excited and had to check the Newcastle Courant's coverage (issue dated 31 March 1848) against some directories (such as this one from 1827)

Top of left-hand page: I was practicing presenting that paper, and evaluating my performance every time I did. Right: developing a visual language that was somewhere between Mary Ann's and Charley's for a couple of pages of Disorder where they talk to each other


This drawing of Mary Ann was the last thing I drew before my appendix burst! I was partway through another presentation rehearsal and feeling increasingly rough, and, to my great inconvenience and surprise, it transpired that one of my internal organs was rupturing. I drew most of the stuff on this spread while I was recovering at home.


More stuff I drew during post-appendectomy recovery. I thought the whole thing was hilarious, especially as I was working on a comic in which my protagonist nearly dies, and then I nearly died! (But I only realised that I nearly died some time after the event. At the time it was just annoying.) Anyway, the experience of having to recover from something that scares the daylights out of everybody around you proved very useful and gave me ideas for when William is recovering from whatever happened to make people despair of his life.


I'd been reading Nigel Llewellyn's The Art of Death (Reaktion Books in association with the V&A, London, 1991) and I developed things that ended up in Disorder. (I've already discussed this book here.) Some of these drawings are influenced by my post-appendix fun.


The first version of William's possibly-weirder-than-the-rest-of-the-book bit. He sees his own corpse, and Bridget in deep mourning, and then encounters their daughter Jane, who is deceased but who remains very cheerful. I wanted this part to be ambiguous - it's unclear whether he's had a supernatural encounter, some sort of prophetic vision, a mildly alarming hallucination, a consciously imagined episode, something induced by medication, or something else. Depends on how you interpret it!


Working out logistics of some of William's pages that show his bed. I don't know what his bed was like at the time when I set the comic (or at any other time), so I used some near-contemporary tent beds, which were apparently cheaper than a four-poster - he's a Yorkshire schoolmaster offering reasonably priced education, he'd probably approve of saving money where you can (I am of Yorkshire descent, I can make these jokes)


Left: by doing that drawing of Benning, I realised I needed to do two more pages in which William expresses his concern over the ophthalmia and becomes increasingly unwell. Right, underneath Bridget and young Ockerby: I drew some rough layouts which became more disordered as William's mental state deteriorates, and, by drawing something disordered, I retitled it - it was going to be called Despaired Of (which came from one of the trial reports, Benning said that William's life was "despaired of") but Disorder can be anything: the ophthalmia was called a disorder, William's mental state is disordered, the narratives are in a disorderly state, and I want to throw ordinary ways of doing history into disorder too.


Ideas for stuff to put on William's two new pages.


Definitions from Frederick Dinsdale's A Glossary of Provincial Words used in Teesdale in the County of Durham (1849, available here) which is very relevant! Teesdale is where the people in my case study lived, and Dinsdale would have been collecting these words during (some of) their lifetimes.


Most of this is me thinking about the written bits (the introduction and the conclusion) in Disorder. I was going to have a glossary full of illustration/ history terms - things from each discipline that people familiar with the other one might not recognise - eventually I decided it was long enough, and I could probably do a bigger and better version of a glossary elsewhere (with more exploration of each term, oh no I sense another postdoctoral thing brewing). Lower right-hand page has a bit about a nasty version of William (I tend to depict him as short-tempered but generally trying to do the right thing)


There's a few spreads like this: I printed a copy of my introduction, cut it up, glued it in, and annotated it. Working out page layout and how the images would work with the words.

A distraction! It's Charley and Ann again! I'm going to do a postdoctoral project about them, focussing on memory/ memorialisation/ commemoration/ forgetting/ misremembering/ that sort of thing.  

Left: a load of symbols and such that appear in the comic in Disorder, that I also included in a couple of places in the introduction, intending on having the audience say "I've seen that before somewhere". Right: printed the conclusion and annotated it like with the introduction. 


I read Beverley Pilcher's Barnard Castle and the Cholera Outbreak, 1849 (2004, privately printed) and had loads of good ideas about Charley and Ann - they went to live in Barnard Castle in the 1840s, and Charley died at the end of the 1849 cholera epidemic. In some of these drawings, I'm wondering how Ann might have reacted to some of the moralistic things that people were saying.

More Disorder conclusion stuff

I am now totally distracted by the idea of that postdoctoral project about Charley and Ann, oh no - leave me to my diversions and go back to the sketchbook index 

Tuesday, August 1, 2023

PhD sketchbooks: A4BD (August 2020 - March 2021)

Not very precise with the dates compared to some of my other sketchbooks! This one mainly contains a lot of final artwork for Disorder. (Timelapse video of this one here!)

The inside front covers of all my PhD sketchbooks carry details for returning them if they go astray. On the right, there's one of Mary Ann's pages, which I planned and analysed in IBH.


Left: planning for a couple of Bridget's pages, with images that never made it into the final comic (William on the anchor and Bridget's heart on fire); this page also has one of the originals for these free printable bookmarks

One of the boys' pages from Disorder. The large canine (wolf? dog? barghest?) is partly made from bits of a newspaper article about the ophthalmia trials (from the Bury & Norwich Post, 5 November 1823) laserprinted and smeared with black ink. 

Another of the boys' pages. Part of the image is made from another laserprinted newspaper article (titled "Cruelty of a Schoolmaster", from the Hull Packet, 10 November 1823) with wax crayon over the top. Some of the other components are made from my old schoolwork. Presence of the researcher's own experiences!

Left: some of my notes discuss turning (what was then called) Despaired Of into a game by printing it out, cutting it up, cropping images to emphasise different parts, writing your own speech bubbles and gluing them on, etc. This ended up being one of Disorder's main themes: audience interpretation. 

I like to include notes on how I made each image, which will be useful if I have to make something similar again. I learnt stuff about working with each medium I used for Disorder while I was making the images. I also had ideas about the content and how I was communicating it and similar stuff - one of the notes on the left page reads "I do not necessarily aim to be renowned for my material accuracy - my work is more about evoking the vibe than 100% realistic reconstruction". (This one also appeared here with pencil for scale)

Drawing this page made me realise that Benning needs to be in the introduction somewhere, otherwise he just turns up on this page like some randomer and the audience wouldn't know who he is. 

I finished the comic, then realised I'd missed something, so I made two more pages in William's visual language (drawing style) and they're my favourites of the lot. This is the first of them. (You'll have to see Disorder itself for the other! It's like this but even more chaotic/ horrific) 

Right: the image of Benning that appears in the introduction of Disorder, and media tests with Charley for the visual language in Disorder's introduction and conclusion.

Stay tuned for more (such as the next one)! Or head back to the sketchbook index.

Characterisation of Charley and Ann - or, Beauty and Sublimity

[Looks like I'd started writing this in 2021, and only now I am getting round to posting it. Hang about, we've got the word "su...